Guests
The authors, researchers, investigators and eyewitnesses who have joined Michael Paul and Mr. Curbs, and the guests coming up next.
Upcoming Guests
Past Guests: Season 2
Daniel
Eyewitness
Daniel recalls the rural Maryland house his family rented in the 1990s: cabinets slamming, objects thrown, and a sound like chains dragged across the basement floor. They moved out within days of the final incident.
Season 2 · Episode 1Halloween Special
Leafy
Eyewitness
Leafy calls himself a skeptical believer. In the home he shares with his boyfriend he describes an attic door that opens by itself, a tall shadow gliding up the stairs, and a ceiling-fan chain yanked by no one.
Season 2 · Episode 1Halloween Special
Myles
Eyewitness
On Halloween night 2021, on a road trip through Wyoming, Myles reports watching a black figure he estimates at 18 feet tall on a distant ridge, circled by birds, with an orb above its head. He supplied the drawing and photographs in the episode's gallery.
Season 2 · Episode 1Halloween Special
Past Guests: Season 1
Wes Clark
Local historian and author
Burbank historian and co-author who spoke with the Bennetts, the couple at the center of the 1970 Bunny Man case, in 2005.
Season 1 · Episode 9The Bunny Man
Read profile »Sheri
Eyewitness
Walking her dog late one night in the 1980s, Sheri looked through an office window and saw a towering figure with a lion's head, in a business suit, calmly filing papers.
Season 1 · Episode 12The Lion Man
Sam
Eyewitness
Sam recounts strange noises and a ghost girl at Maryland's Governor's Goatman Bridge, claw marks found on his car after a visit, a witch's grave, and a childhood sighting of a pale man in a top hat.
Season 1 · Episode 11The Goat Man
Derreck
Eyewitness
Derreck describes seeing a dragonfly-sized winged figure through his backyard window in broad daylight, and a silent girl outside a sliding glass door when he was ten. He also talks about his family's connection to Loveland Castle.
Season 1 · Episode 10Fairies / The Loveland Castle
Olivia
Witchcraft practitioner
Olivia explains her own practice of witchcraft, built on faith, prayer, crystals and intention, and what media portrayals get wrong about it.
Season 1 · Episode 8Positive Witchcraft
Spock
Eyewitness
Spock describes waking paralyzed at 15 in Connecticut, with a hunched figure with speckled brown skin at the foot of his bed, and later a glowing orange object in the sky. He was the first guest to report seeing an alien face in clear detail.
Season 1 · Episode 7Alien Encounter / UFO Sighting
Guest E
Eyewitness
Around 3 AM in a college fraternity house, E woke to green light filling the building and a towering dark figure with an oversized head standing in his doorway. He moved out afterward.
Season 1 · Episode 6Fraternity ET Encounter
Nate
Eyewitness
Nate recalls a feathered humanoid inside his childhood home, a bulldog-like creature in the woods, and years of hostile figures, until a spiritual experience he credits with ending them.
Season 1 · Episode 5Demonic Humanoids
Lena
Eyewitness
At 10 years old in Baltimore, Lena saw a shadowy figure in a brimmed hat. Unlike most Hatman accounts, she remembers feeling calm and safe, with no sleep paralysis and no fear.
Season 1 · Episode 4The Peaceful Hatman of Baltimore
Phil
Eyewitness
Phil reports a close encounter with a reddish-furred Sasquatch while playing airsoft as a teenager in northeastern Ohio, footprints in the mud, wood knocking, and a UFO sighting in the same region.
Season 1 · Episode 3Ohio Bigfoot Encounters
John
Undertaker and eyewitness
An undertaker who says the sound of bells has followed him since childhood, after he first heard the story of the Jingle Man from his father. The sounds return on cold, quiet winter nights.
Season 1 · Episode 2The Jingle Man
Fang
Eyewitness
Our first guest. Fang describes encounters in the woods near his Indiana home: the Slothman, a gray skeletal creature in the tree canopy, and repeated sightings of the Woman in White along roads and forest edges.
Season 1 · Episode 1The Slothman / Woman in White
Accounts are presented as guests reported them, not as independently verified events. A silhouette marks a guest without a published photograph.